{
  "benchmark": {
    "kind": "Arithmetic benchmark, not an independent collision-level or causal replication",
    "paper": {
      "url": "https://jech.bmj.com/content/78/7/437",
      "retained_url": "https://pureadmin.qub.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/627122297/437.full.pdf",
      "doi": "10.1136/jech-2023-221612",
      "sha256": "6b75b131c439f7b3de2634d49c2750d6e030b1a7f9f9ab885c1baf0ab25687c5",
      "licence": "CC BY 4.0, stated on retained PDF cover",
      "tables": "Table1 printed page439; Table2 printed page440"
    },
    "table1_calculation": "100*((post_count/1.83)/(pre_count/3)-1); subtract retained30 percentage change for difference in percentage points. Printed postduration is approximate.",
    "table1": [
      {
        "outcome": "collisions",
        "road_category": "existing20",
        "before_count": 354,
        "after_count": 121,
        "pre_years": 3,
        "post_years_printed": 1.83,
        "pre_annual_rate": 118.0,
        "post_annual_rate": 66.12021857923497,
        "change_pct": -43.965916458275444,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -9.58056835312847,
        "relative_rate_ratio_change_pct": -14.601263706285083
      },
      {
        "outcome": "casualties",
        "road_category": "existing20",
        "before_count": 389,
        "after_count": 139,
        "pre_years": 3,
        "post_years_printed": 1.83,
        "pre_annual_rate": 129.66666666666666,
        "post_annual_rate": 75.95628415300546,
        "change_pct": -41.42188882801635,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -7.767941413406184,
        "relative_rate_ratio_change_pct": -11.708219420301692
      },
      {
        "outcome": "collisions",
        "road_category": "new20",
        "before_count": 1568,
        "after_count": 550,
        "pre_years": 3,
        "post_years_printed": 1.83,
        "pre_annual_rate": 522.6666666666666,
        "post_annual_rate": 300.54644808743166,
        "change_pct": -42.49749079959854,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -8.112142694451563,
        "relative_rate_ratio_change_pct": -12.363309809905276
      },
      {
        "outcome": "casualties",
        "road_category": "new20",
        "before_count": 1757,
        "after_count": 613,
        "pre_years": 3,
        "post_years_printed": 1.83,
        "pre_annual_rate": 585.6666666666666,
        "post_annual_rate": 334.9726775956284,
        "change_pct": -42.80489284081472,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -9.150945426204558,
        "relative_rate_ratio_change_pct": -13.792750389221652
      },
      {
        "outcome": "collisions",
        "road_category": "retained30",
        "before_count": 802,
        "after_count": 321,
        "pre_years": 3,
        "post_years_printed": 1.83,
        "pre_annual_rate": 267.3333333333333,
        "post_annual_rate": 175.40983606557376,
        "change_pct": -34.385348105146974,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": 0.0,
        "relative_rate_ratio_change_pct": 0.0
      },
      {
        "outcome": "casualties",
        "road_category": "retained30",
        "before_count": 934,
        "after_count": 378,
        "pre_years": 3,
        "post_years_printed": 1.83,
        "pre_annual_rate": 311.3333333333333,
        "post_annual_rate": 206.55737704918033,
        "change_pct": -33.653947414610165,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": 0.0,
        "relative_rate_ratio_change_pct": 0.0
      }
    ],
    "table1_rounding_note": "The new20 collision contrast is approximately -8.11pp and the casualty contrast -9.15pp using printed counts/durations. Paper reports -8 and -10 respectively. The casualty figure does not exactly reproduce from these printed inputs; retain this discrepancy rather than claiming exact replication.",
    "table2_calculation": "100*(implementation_post/pre-1)-100*(control_post/pre-1), using printed annual rates; units are percentage points, not a relative risk reduction.",
    "table2": [
      {
        "outcome": "collisions",
        "implementation_pre_rate": 897,
        "implementation_post_rate": 593,
        "control_pre_rate": 587,
        "control_post_rate": 519,
        "implementation_change_pct": -33.89074693422519,
        "control_change_pct": -11.584327086882451,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -22.306419847342738,
        "paper_rounded_difference_pp": -22
      },
      {
        "outcome": "casualties",
        "implementation_pre_rate": 1014,
        "implementation_post_rate": 680,
        "control_pre_rate": 703,
        "control_post_rate": 610,
        "implementation_change_pct": -32.938856015779095,
        "control_change_pct": -13.229018492176392,
        "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -19.7098375236027,
        "paper_rounded_difference_pp": -20
      }
    ],
    "author_workbook": {
      "source_repository_path": "data/injuries data.xlsx",
      "sha256": "6126eeb15272db42f66b3dc7d4859e6f9acc474ff68db0c0efd4dd0c95786330",
      "source_headers": [
        "zone",
        "speed_before",
        "speed after",
        "injuries_before",
        "injuries_after",
        "years"
      ],
      "rows": [
        {
          "zone": "1a",
          "speed_before": 24.14,
          "speed_after": 22.07,
          "source_injuries_before": 469,
          "source_injuries_after": 395,
          "source_post_years": 3.42
        },
        {
          "zone": "1b",
          "speed_before": 23.84,
          "speed_after": 21.43,
          "source_injuries_before": 64,
          "source_injuries_after": 66,
          "source_post_years": 3.42
        },
        {
          "zone": "2",
          "speed_before": 23.53,
          "speed_after": 22.2,
          "source_injuries_before": 645,
          "source_injuries_after": 396,
          "source_post_years": 2.83
        },
        {
          "zone": "3",
          "speed_before": 25.4,
          "speed_after": 23.89,
          "source_injuries_before": 850,
          "source_injuries_after": 536,
          "source_post_years": 2.83
        },
        {
          "zone": "4",
          "speed_before": 26.54,
          "speed_after": 25.75,
          "source_injuries_before": 188,
          "source_injuries_after": 114,
          "source_post_years": 2.63
        },
        {
          "zone": "5",
          "speed_before": 20.14,
          "speed_after": 18.97,
          "source_injuries_before": 268,
          "source_injuries_after": 125,
          "source_post_years": 2.63
        },
        {
          "zone": "6",
          "speed_before": 20.25,
          "speed_after": 20.66,
          "source_injuries_before": 206,
          "source_injuries_after": 72,
          "source_post_years": 1.83
        },
        {
          "zone": "all",
          "speed_before": 23.63,
          "speed_after": 22.29,
          "source_injuries_before": 2690,
          "source_injuries_after": 1704,
          "source_post_years": null
        }
      ],
      "interpretation": "Despite workbook field names injuries_before/after, authors md/injuries code.Rmd treats these as collision counts; pre2690/3 approximates Table2 collision rate897.",
      "pre_rate": 896.6666666666666,
      "post_rate_sum_of_zone_rates": 594.342730555465,
      "implementation_change_pct": -33.716424101621,
      "control_change_pct_from_published_table": -11.584327086882451,
      "difference_in_percentage_changes_pp": -22.132097014738548,
      "comparison": "Rounds to published -22pp collision contrast; rates differ slightly because workbook zone exposure years and published rates are rounded. Control rates are taken from the paper, not independently reconstructed."
    },
    "pairing_audit": "Published Table2 lists zones1a,1b,3,4,5,6 but no zone2 row. Author workbook contains zone2 and its all total includes it; the repository has six control-zone code files and no controlzone2 file. Pairing completeness was not reconciled in this bounded benchmark, so agreement of overall arithmetic does not validate the underlying matched comparison.",
    "not_replicated": [
      "Original STATS19-to-road assignment and junction corrections",
      "Matched control microdata, manual control selection and uncertainty intervals",
      "GAM casualty trend model and causal attribution",
      "Exact legal road history and reuse permissions for GIS"
    ],
    "raw_casualty_zip_limit": "edin_casualties_data.zip has only Accident_Index and Casualty_Severity. It cannot establish dates/geography without collision records; its filename does not establish that all records are Edinburgh."
  },
  "gis": {
    "source": "https://github.com/20mph-study/collision_analysis",
    "source_zip_sha256": "73132e228a539eb697354541c1218b30d8952f4d031348bdb9d59ff2da57b5e6",
    "repository_tree_sha": "d9e9c71dc63e5290575f58c5f24422cf35ff3acd",
    "repository_license_metadata": null,
    "license_named_files": [],
    "license_conclusion": "No explicit GIS reuse licence verified. The paper CC BY licence is not assumed to cover repository GIS.",
    "datasets": [
      {
        "file": "ImplementationZones20mph/ImplementationZones20mph.dbf",
        "features": 7,
        "fields": [
          [
            "Implementa",
            "C",
            50
          ],
          [
            "Implemen_1",
            "C",
            50
          ]
        ],
        "shape_type": 5,
        "bounding_box": [
          309580.70007324405,
          659269.000122074,
          332968.3000000008,
          679829.5000000002
        ],
        "metadata_dates": {
          "CreaDate": "20151118",
          "ModDate": "20190411",
          "mdDateSt": "20190411"
        },
        "attribute_counts": {
          "Implementa": {
            "Zone 1": 2,
            "Zone 2": 1,
            "Zone 4": 1,
            "Zone 5": 1,
            "Zone 6": 1,
            "Zone 3": 1
          },
          "Implemen_1": {
            "Zone 1,  31 Jul 2016": 2,
            "Zone 2,  28 Feb 2017": 1,
            "Zone 4,  16 Aug 2017": 1,
            "Zone 5,  16 Aug 2017": 1,
            "Zone 6,  5 Mar 2018": 1,
            "Zone 3,  28 Feb 2017": 1
          }
        },
        "zone_rows": [
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 1",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 1,  31 Jul 2016"
          },
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 2",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 2,  28 Feb 2017"
          },
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 4",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 4,  16 Aug 2017"
          },
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 5",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 5,  16 Aug 2017"
          },
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 6",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 6,  5 Mar 2018"
          },
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 1",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 1,  31 Jul 2016"
          },
          {
            "Implementa": "Zone 3",
            "Implemen_1": "Zone 3,  28 Feb 2017"
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "file": "ImplementationZones20mph/SpeedLimts20mph.dbf",
        "features": 7478,
        "fields": [
          [
            "FEATID",
            "F",
            19
          ],
          [
            "LAYER",
            "C",
            200
          ]
        ],
        "shape_type": 13,
        "bounding_box": [
          309970.176,
          662774.4670000002,
          332733.0910000001,
          678792.6931
        ],
        "metadata_dates": {
          "CreaDate": "20160212",
          "ModDate": "20190411",
          "mdDateSt": "20190411"
        },
        "attribute_counts": {
          "LAYER": {
            "20mph existing streets": 2774,
            "30mph": 573,
            "20mph streets": 3814,
            "50, 60 or 70mph": 123,
            "Trunk roads": 42,
            "40mph": 123,
            "Part time 20mph": 29
          }
        },
        "zone_rows": null
      }
    ],
    "eligibility": "Historical research road geometry and phased dates are available. Exact legal segment-by-segment TRO validity and subsequent amendments have not been independently verified. No adjacent-road cohort has yet been defined or validated."
  }
}
