{
  "asOf": "2026-11-04",
  "scope": "Bounded primary-source search and access audit. No new national economic or air-quality effect estimate.",
  "costs": [
    {
      "id": "forecast2022",
      "label": "2022 regulatory forecast",
      "amountGBP": 32500000,
      "date": "2022-06-21",
      "status": "Forecast, not expenditure",
      "basis": "Table 4 note: discounted 2022-price present value over a 30-year appraisal. Header says current prices; preserve that ambiguity.",
      "scope": "Main expected spending in 2022–2027. Excludes already-sunk taskforce and RIA costs.",
      "url": "https://senedd.wales/media/fo3ibze5/sub-ld15187-em-e.pdf",
      "display": "£32.500m",
      "limit": "Forecast, not expenditure. Table 4 note: discounted 2022-price present value over a 30-year appraisal. Header says current prices; preserve that ambiguity. Main expected spending in 2022–2027. Excludes already-sunk taskforce and RIA costs."
    },
    {
      "id": "feb2025",
      "label": "February 2025 disclosure",
      "amountGBP": 34692377.11,
      "date": "2025-02-10",
      "status": "Mixed paid and awarded",
      "basis": "Earlier financial years claimed and paid; FY2024/25 awarded. No constant price basis stated.",
      "scope": "Pilots, local authorities, communication, consultancy, research and marketing. Not a final audited national outturn.",
      "url": "https://www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2025-02/atisn23254.pdf",
      "display": "£34.692m",
      "limit": "Mixed paid and awarded. Earlier financial years claimed and paid; FY2024/25 awarded. No constant price basis stated. Pilots, local authorities, communication, consultancy, research and marketing. Not a final audited national outturn."
    },
    {
      "id": "may2025",
      "label": "May 2025 spending disclosure",
      "amountGBP": 39504081,
      "date": "2025-05-19",
      "status": "Approximately spent to date; provisional",
      "basis": "FY2024/25 outturn still being finalised. No common price year or annual payment schedule supplied.",
      "scope": "Includes the separate FY2024/25 Operation Ugain grant. Earlier 20mph policing cannot be separated from normal operations. Do not add the grant again.",
      "url": "https://www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2025-05/atisn24656.pdf",
      "display": "Around £39.504m",
      "limit": "Approximately spent to date; provisional. FY2024/25 outturn still being finalised. No common price year or annual payment schedule supplied. Includes the separate FY2024/25 Operation Ugain grant. Earlier 20mph policing cannot be separated from normal operations. Do not add the grant again."
    },
    {
      "id": "faq",
      "label": "Current government FAQ",
      "amountGBP": 32000000,
      "date": "2026-03-03",
      "status": "Rounded implementation figure",
      "basis": "No accounting period or price year given.",
      "scope": "The FAQ remains around £32m; its scope is not reconciled with the broader May 2025 disclosure.",
      "url": "https://www.gov.wales/introducing-20mph-speed-limits-frequently-asked-questions",
      "display": "Around £32.000m",
      "limit": "Rounded implementation figure. No accounting period or price year given. The FAQ remains around £32m; its scope is not reconciled with the broader May 2025 disclosure."
    },
    {
      "id": "reviewAllocation",
      "label": "Funding for revised limits",
      "amountGBP": 5000000,
      "date": "2024-07-16",
      "status": "FY2024/25 funding availability",
      "basis": "Allocation announcement, not actual expenditure.",
      "scope": "Support for authority changes under revised guidance. Do not add to cumulative spending without reconciling overlap.",
      "url": "https://www.gov.wales/new-framework-support-councils-20mph",
      "display": "£5.000m",
      "limit": "FY2024/25 funding availability. Allocation announcement, not actual expenditure. Support for authority changes under revised guidance. Do not add to cumulative spending without reconciling overlap."
    },
    {
      "id": "grants2025",
      "label": "Published FY2025/26 awards",
      "amountGBP": 5107052,
      "date": "2025-04-11",
      "status": "Sum of 17 named grant awards",
      "basis": "Awards, not measured expenditure. Sum is derived from the 17 explicitly labelled 20mph implementation rows.",
      "scope": "Missing authority entries are not zero; not necessarily a complete national programme cost. Do not add directly to cumulative spent-to-date figures.",
      "url": "https://www.gov.wales/local-authority-transport-grants-awarded-2025-2026",
      "display": "£5.107m",
      "limit": "Sum of 17 named grant awards. Awards, not measured expenditure. Sum is derived from the 17 explicitly labelled 20mph implementation rows. Missing authority entries are not zero; not necessarily a complete national programme cost. Do not add directly to cumulative spent-to-date figures."
    }
  ],
  "costDecision": "No observed national cost-benefit total. These disclosures lack a reconciled scope, annual cash-flow schedule and consistent price basis. Published allocations are not expenditure. For a prospective retain/reverse decision, already-sunk implementation spending is excluded; an ex-post whole-policy appraisal includes historical costs on their actual dates.",
  "maintenance": {
    "measuredIncrementalAnnualCost": null,
    "note": "The 2022 appraisal assumes routine sign maintenance is unchanged from the old signs, so is not incremental. This is an assumption, not observed evidence of zero recurring policy costs."
  },
  "enforcement": {
    "note": "GoSafe reports £570,000 extra roadside engagement for FY2023/24 and a £2.8m general grant in each of FY2023/24 and FY2024/25. The May 2025 FOI instead describes a separate 20mph grant only in FY2024/25. Timing or scope is unreconciled; do not sum these figures or allocate every general policing cost to 20mph.",
    "url": "https://www.gosafe.org/campaigns-and-operations/20mph-engagement-and-enforcement/20mph-enforcement/",
    "evidenceStatus": "Primary-source search text verified; direct local fetch returned 403, no original file retained."
  },
  "journeys": {
    "latestReportFound": "2025-07-15",
    "indexChecked": "2026-11-04",
    "periods": {
      "spring2023": "February–April 2023",
      "spring2024": "February–April 2024",
      "autumn2024": "September–November 2024"
    },
    "sampling": "Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays; Easter public holidays avoided.",
    "routes": 15,
    "comparisonRows": 60,
    "observations": 180,
    "primaryComparison": "Same-season spring 2023 versus spring 2024; still uncontrolled.",
    "secondaryComparison": "Spring 2023 versus autumn 2024 changes both policy period and season.",
    "rangeLabel": "The 5th–95th percentile range measures journey variability, not a confidence interval.",
    "nationalWeighting": "No traveller, vehicle-flow or purpose weights supplied for these 60 combinations. Do not project an unweighted route average to Wales.",
    "roadworks": "No route-by-period roadworks or concurrent-scheme log found. The report’s roadworks-free statement applies to speed monitoring sites, not journey routes. Annex B is a route map.",
    "routeKm": [
      61,
      29,
      27,
      32,
      18,
      20,
      25,
      12,
      9,
      11,
      10,
      8,
      9,
      7,
      5
    ],
    "url": "https://tfw.wales/national-monitoring-report-july-2025",
    "indexUrl": "https://tfw.wales/about-us/transparency/publications/default-20mph-speed-limit",
    "reportUrl": "https://tfw.wales/national-monitoring-report-july-2025",
    "workbookUrl": "https://tfw.wales/sites/default/files/2025-07/Vehicle_journey_times_Feb23_to_Nov24.ods"
  },
  "traffic": {
    "date": "2026-05-05",
    "note": "Welsh Government did not hold the requested 2018-onward volume-by-speed-limit dataset. TfW had a small monitored-road sample from 2021 or 2023. DfT mileage by road classification or authority does not provide affected person trips on these journey routes. The evaluator had not yet judged external traffic data sufficient at the response date.",
    "url": "https://www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2026-05/atisn26597_0.pdf"
  },
  "airQuality": {
    "decision": "Coverage gate not met; no new causal model",
    "pilotReportDate": "2024-05-09",
    "pilotUrl": "https://tfw.wales/sites/default/files/2024-05/20mph-phase-1-air-quality-monitoring-report.docx",
    "baselineBeforePilot": false,
    "coverage": [
      {
        "location": "Cardiff outside site 1",
        "period": "May 2022–May 2023"
      },
      {
        "location": "Cardiff outside site 2",
        "period": "May 2023–March 2024"
      },
      {
        "location": "Magor",
        "period": "June 2022–April 2024"
      },
      {
        "location": "Abergavenny",
        "period": "March 2023–April 2024"
      }
    ],
    "limitations": [
      "No pre-implementation air-quality baseline in the pilot.",
      "Cardiff outside sensor moved on 17 May 2023 after a new crossing; construction periods were excluded.",
      "Magor bridge-closure traffic period was excluded.",
      "Calibration and solar-power gaps; sensors not reference-equivalent.",
      "No outside-area traffic monitoring in Cardiff or Magor.",
      "Modelled weather may not represent the local sites."
    ],
    "accessAudit": [
      {
        "item": "Hourly pollution measurements and site metadata",
        "status": "Available",
        "url": "https://www.airquality.gov.wales/maps-data/measurements"
      },
      {
        "item": "Ratification and provisional status",
        "status": "Available; not all local authority stations receive the full QA process",
        "url": "https://www.airquality.gov.wales/maps-data/measurements/ratification-process"
      },
      {
        "item": "Weather",
        "status": "10km WRF model available; local representativeness limited",
        "url": "https://www.airquality.gov.wales/maps-data/openair-introduction"
      },
      {
        "item": "Dated treated/control roadside pairs and hourly capture",
        "status": "Not verified in this phase",
        "url": null
      }
    ],
    "interpretation": "Published paired post-only observations cannot identify the policy-induced change. Ambient NO2 and particles are not measures of carbon emissions or fuel use.",
    "conclusion": "The existing TfW pilot did not collect a pre-implementation air-quality baseline. Sensor relocation, construction, calibration gaps and incomplete comparison-site traffic information limit its post-only comparisons. That does not establish either a policy effect or no effect.",
    "nextEvidence": "Hourly pollution and quality flags are publicly available, but dated treatment/control pairs, usable before/after capture and suitable local weather have not been verified for a national study. The optional causal analysis therefore does not proceed.",
    "sourceUrl": "https://tfw.wales/sites/default/files/2024-05/20mph-phase-1-air-quality-monitoring-report.docx"
  },
  "missingInputs": [
    "A credible policy-induced casualty change by severity, allowing for recording transitions and displaced harm.",
    "A policy-induced journey change and representative traffic, occupancy and purpose weights for the same roads, people and periods.",
    "A reconciled payment schedule, incremental maintenance and enforcement costs, and any reversal costs, converted to one price basis.",
    "Other effects: vehicle operating costs, reliability, active travel, air quality and carbon, plus any double-counting checks."
  ]
}
