{
  "release": "20mph-phase5-v5",
  "asOf": "2026-11-04",
  "status": "Retrospective conditional illustration; existing outcomes known",
  "approvalScope": "Phase 5 trade-offs from 3 November 2026 plan. Phase 6 article not commissioned.",
  "causalGate": "Not met in phase 3; no national net-benefit estimate.",
  "defaultAssumptions": {
    "tripsPerDay": 100000,
    "daysPerYear": 250,
    "occupancy": 1.5,
    "delaySeconds": 30,
    "purpose": "commute",
    "years": 10,
    "upfrontCost": 0,
    "annualCost": 0,
    "fatal": 0,
    "serious": 0,
    "slight": 0
  },
  "defaultStatus": "All cohort inputs illustrative. Zero costs exclude unentered components. Zero casualty placeholders are not a zero-benefit finding; policy balance withheld until user explicitly enters a scenario.",
  "periods": {
    "journeyPrimary": "February–April 2023 versus February–April 2024, Tuesdays–Thursdays, Easter public holidays avoided",
    "journeySecondary": "Spring 2023 versus September–November 2024, changes season",
    "scenario": "Hypothetical future cohort; upfront 2026, annual end-year flows 2027 onward for 1–30 years. Not historical policy appraisal."
  },
  "unitRules": [
    "Vehicle trips multiplied by occupancy exactly once to obtain person trips.",
    "Delay entered in seconds; divide by 3600 to obtain person hours.",
    "Percentile spreads are not confidence intervals or standard deviations.",
    "No traveller weights, no inferential test across overlapping route combinations, no national extrapolation.",
    "Each severity-equivalent threshold is an alternative, not an additive requirement.",
    "A fixed number of annual casualties prevented; negative values allow additional injuries. No severity mix inferred from phase 3.",
    "No double-count of NHS/medical cost or collision values.",
    "2023 market prices, 2026 valuation and PV reference explicitly distinct. No escalation of nominal budgets into scenario defaults."
  ],
  "omissions": [
    "causal identification",
    "national affected volumes",
    "observed occupancy/purpose",
    "damage-only collisions",
    "vehicle operating effects",
    "reliability valuation",
    "active travel",
    "air quality",
    "carbon emissions",
    "insurance premiums",
    "wider economic effects",
    "residual asset values"
  ],
  "airQualityGate": "Coverage screen fails for existing pilot; national treated/control/hourly capture remains unverified."
}
