{
  "id": "20mph-publication-v6-2026-11-05",
  "publishedDate": "2026-11-05",
  "evidenceDate": "2026-11-04",
  "title": "20mph limits: where do they improve safety, and what do drivers give up?",
  "deck": "The Welsh evidence shows lower measured speeds and longer sampled journeys. A credible national causal effect and net-benefit figure remain unresolved.",
  "causalGate": "Not met",
  "nationalNetBenefit": null,
  "approval": {
    "basis": "User instruction to implement the next approved phase",
    "scope": "Phase 6 publication and quality checks",
    "independentEditorialSignOff": false
  },
  "valuationNotice": "The scenarios retain May 2026 TAG v2.03 inputs for reproducibility. On 5 November 2026, DfT announced revised discounting and economic parameters for its expected December release, following Treasury’s October changes. Those revisions are not included in this version; updated calculations will require a separate version.",
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "safety",
      "title": "Fewer collisions than 2022, but an increase in 2025",
      "text": "Police-recorded injury collisions on all Welsh roads fell from 3,316 in 2022 to 3,005 in 2025 (-9.4%). The 2025 count was higher than 2024’s 2,919.",
      "status": "Observed counts",
      "period": "2022–2025; StatsWales release 29 October 2026",
      "limitation": "Counts are not exposure-adjusted risk. The decline predates the national policy; this comparison does not identify its effect.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v2/pilot.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "annual[year=2022,2024,2025].collisions_all"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://stats.gov.wales/en-GB/449cb665-6275-4a61-b7f9-a536207be2e0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "comparison",
      "title": "The estimated reduction depends on the comparator",
      "text": "The weighted English comparison gives a -9.7% collision association (95% calendar-HAC interval -14.8% to -4.4%). Pooling England gives -3.1% (-10.1% to +4.5%).",
      "status": "Model associations; not causal",
      "period": "Post: October 2023–December 2025; pre: 2015–2019 and January 2022–August 2023",
      "limitation": "The intervals condition on the model. Comparison areas are not verified untreated; pre-trends and fake-date tests weaken identification. These are not bounds on a causal effect.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v3/results.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "main.collisions",
        "sensitivity[id=pooled-england,outcome=collisions]",
        "fit",
        "placebos",
        "causalGate"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/road-safety-open-data"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "speed",
      "title": "Measured speeds fell at retained sites",
      "text": "The weighted mean at 38 retained monitoring sites fell from 28.5mph in summer 2023 to 25.2mph in summer 2025.",
      "status": "Observed sample",
      "period": "Summer 2023–summer 2025",
      "limitation": "These selected main through roads are not representative of every 20mph road. Five sites reverted to 30mph and are excluded throughout.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v2/pilot.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "speeds[period=Summer 2023,Summer 2025]"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://tfw.wales/vehicle-speed-monitoring-data-july-2023-to-september-2025"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "journeys",
      "title": "Most sampled journeys took longer",
      "text": "Of 60 route/direction/peak combinations, 53 had longer mean journeys, 1 was unchanged and 6 were shorter. The median change in the mean was +37.5 seconds.",
      "status": "Observed sample",
      "period": "Spring 2023–spring 2024; same season",
      "limitation": "Combinations have equal weight, overlap and are not independent experiments. This is not a national traveller-weighted delay or a policy effect.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v5/results.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "journeySummary.spring",
        "journeys"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://tfw.wales/national-monitoring-report-july-2025",
        "https://tfw.wales/sites/default/files/2025-07/Vehicle_journey_times_Feb23_to_Nov24.ods"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "variation",
      "title": "Longer and less variable can occur together",
      "text": "The observed 95th–5th percentile time spread narrowed in 50 of 60 combinations; 44 became both longer on average and narrower in spread.",
      "status": "Observed sample",
      "period": "Spring 2023–spring 2024",
      "limitation": "The percentile spread is neither a confidence interval nor a standard deviation. It cannot alone price reliability benefits.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v5/results.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "journeySummary.spring.narrowerSpread",
        "journeySummary.spring.longerAndNarrower",
        "journeys"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://tfw.wales/national-monitoring-report-july-2025"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "local",
      "title": "Local patterns do not establish where the policy works",
      "text": "Subgroup associations differ across road users and settings. Collision-neighbourhood deprivation describes the place of the event, not the injured person’s income. Recorded speed-category differences do not demonstrate traffic diversion.",
      "status": "Exploratory associations",
      "period": "2015–2025; same main pre/post windows as the comparison",
      "limitation": "No causal adjacent-road diversion estimate or road-specific reversal casualty effect is identified. Multiple comparisons and nonparallel pre-trends remain relevant.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v4/results.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "groups",
        "heterogeneity",
        "causalGate"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/road-safety-open-data"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "cost",
      "title": "Spending disclosures have different scopes",
      "text": "A 19 May 2025 Welsh Government disclosure reported approximately £39.504m spent to date. The annual outturn was still being finalised and the total included the separate Operation Ugain grant for 2024/25.",
      "status": "Provisional reported expenditure",
      "period": "Disclosure: 19 May 2025",
      "limitation": "This is not a final lifetime cost. Forecasts, awards and spending disclosures are not additive, and do not share a validated payment schedule and price basis.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v5/inputs/evidence-context.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "costs[id=may2025]"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2025-05/atisn24656.pdf"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "scenario",
      "title": "A break-even illustration is not a verdict",
      "text": "Assume 100,000 car trips per day, 250 days per year, 1.5 people per car, 30 seconds of policy-induced delay, commuting values and ten years. With implementation and recurring costs excluded, the included time cost has a £44.39m present value. Preventing 16.03 serious casualties each year would be one alternative equivalent threshold.",
      "status": "Hypothetical; frozen May 2026 TAG v2.03",
      "period": "£2023 market prices; 2026 present-value reference; annual flows 2027–2036",
      "limitation": "Every traffic and effect input is assumed. No casualty effect is selected by default; benefit and balance stay null. Missing impacts are not zero. This is not a Wales appraisal or a forecast of insurer or NHS cash savings.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v5/results.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "scenarios[delaySeconds=30,purpose=commute]",
        "valuation"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/tag-data-book",
        "https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6a576e102f6185941a9a6569/tag-data-book-v2-03.xlsm"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "air",
      "title": "The air-quality question remains open",
      "text": "The pilot did not collect a pre-implementation air-quality baseline. Sensor changes, gaps and incomplete traffic comparisons limit its post-only observations. A new causal model was not advanced.",
      "status": "Coverage gate not met",
      "period": "Pilot report: May 2024; feasibility review: 4 November 2026",
      "limitation": "This establishes neither an effect nor no effect. Ambient nitrogen dioxide and particles are not measurements of carbon emissions or fuel use.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v5/inputs/evidence-context.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "airQuality"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://tfw.wales/sites/default/files/2024-05/20mph-phase-1-air-quality-monitoring-report.docx"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "vintage",
      "title": "Valuation guidance is changing",
      "text": "The scenarios retain May 2026 TAG v2.03 inputs for reproducibility. On 5 November 2026, DfT announced revised discounting and economic parameters for its expected December release, following Treasury’s October changes. Those revisions are not included in this version; updated calculations will require a separate version.",
      "status": "Dated guidance notice",
      "period": "Checked 5 November 2026",
      "limitation": "Frozen rates must not be described as the latest Green Book recommendations. No silent replacement of historical calculations.",
      "release": "/research/20mph/v6/publication.json",
      "evidencePaths": [
        "valuationNotice"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/tag-data-book",
        "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/forthcoming-changes-and-previous-versions-of-tag/forthcoming-change-discount-rate-changes-in-tag",
        "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/forthcoming-changes-and-previous-versions-of-tag/forthcoming-change-updates-to-tag-economic-and-demographic-parameters"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "article": [
    {
      "id": "safety",
      "heading": "Safety: a fall in counts is only the start",
      "claimIds": [
        "safety",
        "comparison"
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "The public debate often asks a single question: did 20mph work? That bundles together several different questions. Were speeds lower? Were fewer people injured? How much of any change was caused by the policy? And were those benefits worth the travel time and other costs? Each needs its own evidence.",
        "Wales is the focus of this lab. The national change took effect in September 2023, but road safety had already been changing. Choosing a favourable before-year can make a simple comparison look decisive. Showing both the longer comparison and the latest annual movement is more informative.",
        "The controlled comparison asks what the Welsh trajectory might have looked like without the change. It is more demanding than a before-and-after calculation, but the counterfactual still fails important checks: English areas had their own 20mph programmes, trends were not parallel, and the model detects breaks at fake dates before the policy. The smaller pooled estimate also has an interval spanning zero. We therefore publish associations, not a count of injuries proved to have been prevented."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "journeys",
      "heading": "Drivers faced a trade-off in the measured sample",
      "claimIds": [
        "speed",
        "journeys",
        "variation"
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "Lower spot speeds do not translate directly into the same percentage increase in whole-journey time. Routes include different limits, junctions and congestion. The lab follows the same route, direction and peak combination across periods and makes spring-to-spring the main comparison.",
        "The route sample shows that many journeys became longer and less variable at the same time. That is useful evidence for the debate, but it does not isolate the policy’s contribution. Traffic volumes, roadworks and other changes may contribute; no validated route weights convert these observations into a national delay. The autumn comparison remains available as a separate sensitivity because it changes the season."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "place",
      "heading": "Where should the limit apply?",
      "claimIds": [
        "local"
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "That is a decision about particular roads and people, not simply a national average. The lab exposes differences across road-user groups, age, road settings and neighbourhoods. Those patterns can help prioritise further investigation; they cannot yet tell a council which road would become safer if its limit changed.",
        "A credible local evaluation needs dated road boundaries and legal changes, comparison roads with verified histories, traffic exposure, and enough before-and-after observations. Roads with no collisions must remain in the denominator. A rise on roads recorded at higher limits is not, by itself, proof that traffic or harm was displaced there."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "balance",
      "heading": "What would the safety gains need to be worth?",
      "claimIds": [
        "cost",
        "scenario",
        "vintage"
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "The economic question cannot be answered by attaching a pound value to the lab’s aggregate casualty association. A defensible appraisal needs a causal change by severity, policy-induced travel time, matching trip volumes and a compatible cost history. Those inputs are not yet jointly established.",
        "The calculator instead lets readers see the assumptions needed to reach a break-even threshold. The illustration is deliberately labelled as hypothetical. Costs set to zero are excluded components, not evidence that implementation was free. Casualty prevention values describe social welfare; they are not equivalent to insurance claim reductions, lower premiums or cash returned to the NHS.",
        "For a decision to retain or reverse a limit now, already-spent implementation money is sunk. The relevant future comparison concerns the costs and outcomes still changeable. An evaluation of the original decision must instead place historical costs on their actual dates. These are different appraisal questions."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "environment",
      "heading": "Do not turn missing environmental evidence into a zero",
      "claimIds": [
        "air"
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "Air quality, emissions, active travel and access may matter to the decision even when this release cannot value them. The absence of an identified effect is not evidence that the effect is absent. They remain explicit gaps rather than hidden zeros in a national total."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "decision",
      "heading": "What the evidence supports now",
      "claimIds": [
        "comparison",
        "journeys",
        "scenario"
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "The defensible conclusion is bounded: speeds fell at the retained monitoring sites; most measured peak-route combinations took longer; and the controlled safety result depends materially on the comparison. This lab does not establish a national causal safety effect or a national net benefit.",
        "The next evidence investment should target those decision gaps: verified treatment and comparison-road histories, matched exposure and journey weights, compatible severity records, and dated costs. Until those are available, publish the observations and their uncertainty together. That gives the public a basis for judging claims without pretending the remaining questions have been settled."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "inputs": {
    "/research/20mph/v2/pilot.json": "79999d624b7a5325ac52870c020cffadb7286b51af0a8b646ff268ad2c3041fc",
    "/research/20mph/v3/results.json": "a83f6febe717be0de23ec3f9a7424bcdd86c646b66890fcc2e535e1f00f39aa6",
    "/research/20mph/v4/results.json": "f100af6fdafe179a10ac5f3cdd707f1b817b5a7ef283b8063355d86afa485b3e",
    "/research/20mph/v5/results.json": "07f68efd279a064f8b93d44c8249b71b577fd87696f93874f87400fb203cdb39"
  },
  "headline": {
    "collisions2022": 3316,
    "collisions2025": 3005,
    "collisionChangePct": -9.378769601930037,
    "journeyMedianSeconds": 37.5,
    "journeysLonger": 53,
    "journeysTotal": 60
  },
  "comparison": [
    {
      "label": "Weighted English regions",
      "pct": -9.74955776738977,
      "ci": [
        -14.760052234651743,
        -4.444541125201405
      ]
    },
    {
      "label": "Pooled England",
      "pct": -3.071686602262891,
      "ci": [
        -10.107984536598957,
        4.515377586067075
      ]
    }
  ],
  "changeLog": [
    {
      "date": "2026-11-05",
      "release": "v6",
      "change": "Published sourced synthesis, five-view navigation, exact claim ledger and accessible data alternatives. Added dated TAG notice; prior numerical releases remain unchanged."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-04",
      "release": "v5",
      "change": "Journey comparisons, cost and air-quality audit, conditional break-even scenarios."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-11-04",
      "release": "v3–v4",
      "change": "Controlled comparisons and exploratory subgroups; causal gate not met."
    }
  ]
}
